Medicare Scam Calls and Fake Agents Are Getting Harder to Spot

September 16, 2026

Who's Really on the Other End of That Medicare Call?


The phone rings. The voice on the other end says your name, your age, and your address. It sounds official. It may even sound friendly. And within a minute, you are being asked to confirm your Medicare number. What do you do?


Complaints about Medicare-related scam calls have climbed sharply over the past year. Reports to the Better Business Bureau indicate that these kinds of calls remain a major concern for people Medicare. Some have even described getting dozens of these calls in a single day. Enrollment season tends to make it worse, because legitimate outreach picks up at the same time criminals do.


Here is how these calls tend to sound, and how to protect yourself.



The Three Pitches You Are Most Likely to Hear


Many Medicare scam calls follow similar scripts. Once you recognize a few key patterns, the calls lose a lot of their power.


"You qualify for extra benefits"


A recorded voice says it is reaching out to make sure you receive unclaimed Medicare benefits. The recording asks whether you have Part A and Part B, then transfers you to a live person. The real goal is either to get your personal information or to switch you to a plan you did not ask for.


"Your card is expiring"


The caller warns that your Medicare card is about to expire, or that your coverage could be interrupted unless you verify a few details. Fear and urgency are the strategy here. If you hand over your Medicare number or Social Security number, criminals can use it to steal your identity or bill you for services you never received.


"Something free is on the way"


Free braces. Free hearing aids. Free gift cards or a free smartphone. The offered gift is bait. One woman in Texas received a large box of orthopedic braces she never ordered, and later learned Medicare had been billed more than $700 for them. Her secondary insurer was charged as well, and additional claims were filed for supplies she never requested.


Fraudulent claims can also leave inaccurate information in your medical records, including diagnoses for conditions you do not have.



Fake Agents Are Part of the Problem


Not every scammer sounds like a robot. Some present themselves as licensed insurance agents. They may reference a well-known carrier, quote a plan name, or offer to walk you through your options right now over the phone.


A few things a real agent will not do:


  • Pressure you to decide something during a first call
  • Refuse to give you a full name, license number, or office phone number
  • Ask you to pay by gift card, wire transfer, or a payment app
  • Tell you that you must act today or lose your coverage
  • Show up at your door uninvited to sell you a plan


Verifying an agent is simpler than most people expect. Ask for their name and license number, then hang up and call the agency's main office number yourself. You can also check the license with your state Department of Insurance. Anyone who is legitimate will not mind you doing this; they know you need to be careful.



Habits That Keep You Safe


  • Treat unexpected Medicare calls with skepticism, even friendly ones
  • Never give your Medicare number, Social Security number, or bank details to someone who called you
  • Remember that Medicare generally reaches out by mail first and does not call to ask for your Medicare number or banking information
  • Hang up on anyone who pressures you or claims your coverage is at risk
  • Read your Medicare Summary Notices and Explanation of Benefits statements and look for charges you do not recognize
  • Report anything unfamiliar right away


Hanging up may feel rude, but it is the single most effective thing you can do.



If You Think You Already Shared Something You Shouldn't Have


Act quickly, but do not panic. Write down what you shared and when. Review your recent statements. Then report it. You can contact the Senior Medicare Patrol program in your state, call 1-800-MEDICARE, or file a report with the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.



The Easiest Defense Is a Person You Already Know


Scam calls work because they catch people on their own and unsure. Having a licensed agent you already trust means you have someone in your corner. You have a number you can call to ask whether an offer is real before you respond to it. If you have questions about a call you received, or you want a second set of eyes on your current coverage, reach out to our office. We are here to help you!

Person holding a glass beside a laptop on a wooden table, with books and decor in the background
October 21, 2026
Learn what's been driving Medicare Advantage plan exits and benefit cuts. Understand the pattern and what to watch for when 2027 plans are announced this October.
October 16, 2026
Press Release: ATLANTA, September 28, 2026 Medicare Caddy, LLC today announced an expanded approach to Medicare guidance built around an increasingly important idea: choosing Medicare coverage should not be treated as a once-a-year transaction. Through its 12-month Medicare Concierge Services , Medicare Caddy provides individuals and couples with personalized guidance before, during and after their enrollment—helping them understand Medicare options, evaluate coverage and costs, complete enrollment, and respond as healthcare needs and coverage options change. The model also creates a new opportunity for financial advisors and wealth management professionals to extend their client service into an area that can significantly affect retirement planning: healthcare coverage. “Financial advisors spend years helping their clients prepare financially for retirement, but when Medicare enters the picture, clients are often left to navigate an entirely different and complicated system on their own,” said Greg O’Brien, Founder, Medicare Caddy, LLC. “We believe there is a better way. Medicare Caddy gives advisors a trusted Medicare resource they can place alongside their clients for an entire year.” From Medicare Enrollment to Medicare Guidance The introduction of Medicare Caddy’s Concierge Services comes as the broader health insurance industry is recognizing increased consumer demand for ongoing advisory relationships. A 2026 eHealth survey of more than 1,500 Americans found that 87% of respondents believe it is important to have an insurance advisor who can help them understand coverage options year-round—not simply during enrollment periods. Medicare Caddy’s approach is designed around that same fundamental need for continuing guidance while focusing specifically on the Medicare decisions facing individuals approaching or living in retirement. The company’s concierge process helps clients: · Understand Medicare eligibility, timelines and coverage options in plain language; · Evaluate insurance plans, companies, networks, prescription coverage and potential costs; · Complete electronic enrollments correctly and on time; · Access Medicare guidance and answers throughout the 12-month concierge period; · Monitor insurance plan changes, particularly prescription drug coverage; and · Conduct an annual review to determine whether existing coverage continues to meet the needs. Each client receives a Medicare Caddy Scorecard—summarizing key benefits, coverage details and insurance plan information to provide peace-of-mind. A New Client-Service Tool for Financial Advisors Medicare decisions do not exist in isolation from financial planning. Premiums, deductibles, prescription costs, provider networks, and potential out-of-pocket expenses can all affect a retiree’s financial well-being. Medicare Caddy Concierge Services are designed to actively complement the important role of the financial advisor. Financial advisors, wealth managers and other professionals serving individuals approaching retirement can provide the 12-month service to clients, giving them direct access to Medicare expertise while allowing the advisor to remain focused on the broader financial relationship. “An advisor does not need to become a Medicare expert,” said O’Brien. “The advisor needs a Medicare expert they trust enough to introduce to a valued client. We want Medicare Caddy to be that resource.” Simple, Transparent Pricing Medicare Caddy’s 12-month Concierge Services are offered at $300 per individual or $500 per couple . The service can be purchased directly or provided by a financial advisor as a client benefit. “Our goal is not simply to help someone select an insurance plan,” said Jordan Wood, Senior Operations Manager. “Our goal is to give people clarity and confidence throughout the Medicare decision-making process—and to be available when the next question arises.” About Medicare Caddy, LLC Medicare Caddy, LLC is a Georgia-based Medicare advisory firm helping individuals and couples navigate Medicare with expert guidance, clear direction, and confidence for the course ahead. Its 12-month Medicare Concierge Service provides personalized support from Medicare education and insurance plan evaluation through enrollment and ongoing annual guidance. Medicare Caddy is an independent insurance agency and advisory service and is not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. For additional information about Medicare Caddy Concierge Services, visit https://www.MedicareCaddy.com.  ### MEDIA CONTACT Jordan Wood Medicare Caddy, LLC 770-668-5040 Jordan.Wood@MedicareCaddy.com
Assorted colorful pills and capsules scattered in a dense pile
October 14, 2026
A temporary Medicare Part D premium program ends after 2026. Learn what it could mean for your 2027 drug plan costs and coverage.
Two people walking arm in arm toward a yellow house with a white porch and garden.
October 7, 2026
Spending part of the year in another state? Learn how Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medigap and Part D may work when you live in two places.
Person doing downward dog on a blue mat in a bright yoga studio
September 23, 2026
The Medicare GLP-1 Bridge program offers certain eligible people access to select weight-management drugs for a $50 copay. Learn what's covered and who may qualify.
Hands typing on a laptop keyboard, with turquoise rings visible on both hands.
September 2, 2026
Annual Enrollment for Medicare runs October 15 – December 7, 2026. Here's what to know about comparing plans, key dates, and how to get ready.
Two masked people talking on a porch, one seated and one standing nearby.
August 19, 2026
A Chronic Condition Special Needs Plan (C-SNP) is a Medicare Advantage plan built around conditions like diabetes or heart failure. See how it works.
Smiling couple in glasses and a patterned headscarf, leaning close together indoors
August 12, 2026
Original Medicare doesn’t cover hearing aids, but you still have options. Here’s a clear breakdown of Medicare Advantage, OTC hearing aids, and other ways to save.
Person holding a stack of mail and bills, sorting through envelopes at a table.
August 8, 2026
Every fall, Medicare Advantage and Part D plans mail an Annual Notice of Change. Learn what it means for your costs, coverage, and doctors next year.
Two travelers wheeling suitcases on a dock toward overwater bungalows and a boat in turquoise water
June 29, 2026
Ten percent of Medicare Advantage plans were discontinued for 2026. Here is what affected beneficiaries should know about their coverage options and rights.
Show More